Scroll vs Screw Compressors: What is the difference?
We’ll compare scroll vs screw compressors along with their pros, cons, and suitable industries and applications for each to help you make an informed decision.
In order to understand different types and technologies of compressors, we first need to understand the two basic principles of compressing air: dynamic and displacement compression. In this article, we talk about the scroll compressor, which is a type of displacement compressor with wide applications in air-conditioning and refrigeration systems, heat pumps, and cars.
A scroll compressor, also known as a spiral compressor and a scroll pump, is a type of positive-displacement compressor that works by internal compression of air or gas. Scroll compressors can be oil-lubricated or oil-free, and the latter is best suited for applications where there is a need for clean, dry air quality without any oil contamination in the compression chamber.
How does a scroll type compressor operate? A scroll compressor consists of two spiral-shaped scroll elements that are bolted together: a stationary scroll and an orbiting scroll driven by a motor. The scrolls oscillate in continuous motion without any metal-to-metal contact while the air is compressed into increasingly smaller volumes in crescent-shaped air pockets. Let’s dive a bit deeper to understand the mechanism of displacement compression in scroll compressors.
The orbiting scroll is driven by a short-stroke crankshaft and runs eccentrically around the center of the fixed scroll. The movement of the orbiting scroll creates suction that draws the air in from the inlet opening that is located at the top of the element housing. Air or gas that is captured in the air pockets between the two scrolls is gradually compressed while moving towards the center of the housing where the outlet port and a non-return valve are found. Compressed and pressurized gas is discharged from the outlet port at the center of the assembly. The non-return valve, or simply the check valve, prevents the backflow of gas or refrigerant.
The 180° rotation or phase displacement provides the radial stability of the scroll element. Because the compression chamber becomes increasingly smaller while air or gas is compressed within the compressor, this type of compression is usually called internal compression. During this process, leakage is minimized because the pressure difference in the air pockets is lower than the pressure difference between the inlet and the outlet. Similar to internal compression in a screw compressor, the amount of internal compression is determined by the design of the discharge port. Due to the unique design of its discharge port, the scroll compressor can compress more air or gas with a relatively lower consumption of power. Compared to other compressors, the scroll compressor attains the highest efficiency level in volume because there are no pistons to compress the gas.
Noise emission of the scroll type compressor is also significantly lower than all the existing compressor technology. The complete compression cycle takes 2.5 turns, including suction, compression, and discharge revolution phases, which take place simultaneously and provide constant flow of pulsation-free air. The scroll compressor offers smooth and vibration-free operation thanks to its scroll element, which hardly has any torque variation compared to a piston compressor. The simple design of the scroll compressor with only one moving part (thus friction-free) makes it highly reliable and quieter compared to equivalent piston compressor or the more traditional rotary screw compressor.
Scroll compressors use two spiral-shaped scrolls to compress air. One scroll remains fixed, while the other moves in an orbiting motion around the center of the stationary scroll. As the scrolls rotate, the orbiting scroll draws air through the inlet, compressing and pushing it towards the center. Finally, the compressed air is released through the outlet.
Scroll compressors consist of two spiral-shaped scroll elements that are bolted together: a stationary scroll and an orbiting scroll driven by a motor. The process of compressing air in a scroll compressor involves several steps:
By following these steps, scroll compressors achieve efficient and reliable air compression.
When most people think of air compressors, they probably imagine a bulky and loud machine. Scroll compressors are pretty much the opposite of that. They are oil-free, compact and relatively silent compared to other types of compressors.
Thanks to the simple design of the scroll compressor with only one moving part, this type of compressor is highly reliable and quieter compared to the piston and rotary screw compressor. This makes them perfect for sensitive working environments, like a dentist’s office. Another advantage of scroll compressors is energy efficiency.
Advantages:
Disadvantages:
Similar to internal compression in a screw compressor, the amount of internal compression is determined by the discharge port. Due to the unique design of the discharge port, the scroll air compressor can compress more air or gas while using minimal power.
Compared to other compressors, these machines attain the highest efficiency level by volume. This is because there are no pistons to compress the gas.
The noise emission of a scroll air compressor is significantly lower than other compressors. The complete compression cycle takes 2.5 turns, including the suction, compression, and discharge revolution phases. These occur simultaneously while providing a constant flow of pulsation-free air.
The scroll air compressor offers smooth and vibration-free operations thanks to its scroll element. It hardly has any torque variation compared to a piston compressor. The simple design of the scroll air compressor contains only one moving part. This makes it highly reliable and quieter than equivalent piston and rotary screw compressors.
Selecting a scroll air compressor involves considering several factors: size, flow, and air quality requirements.
Determine Needs:
Capacity & Flow:
Choosing a scroll compressor ultimately depends on the size, flow and quality requirements of your application. Before choosing any type of scroll compressor, it is important to figure out the correct size and technology for your compressed air needs, starting with whether you need an oil-free or lubricated compressor. For higher capacity and flow, it is possible to choose units with two or four scroll compressor elements in one housing. However, it may be more economical in some cases to go for a single large compressor rather than teaming up several scroll compressors to produce sufficient flow.
The scroll compressor has many advantages due to its simplified yet efficient design. With fewer components than reciprocating compressors, it ensures a high level of operational reliability and requires hardly any maintenance. Many leading industrial applications go for the scroll compressor because it meets all the basic requirements of a general-purpose compressor. Whereas oil-injected screw compressors may be more efficient in large industrial applications with larger volume demands, scroll compressors are still widely used in food, refrigeration, air-conditioning, and transportation industries.
There is an abundance of applications for quiet and energy-efficient compressors that produce absolutely clean air. Take the SF scroll compressor series from Atlas Copco, which has been a leader in this field for more than 60 years. Its unique characteristics make it ideal for many manufacturing processes for which clean, oil-free compressed air is a prerequisite. That is why the SF is the preferred choice for sensitive indoor environments, like hospitals but also labs, breweries, bakeries, dairy farms, electronics manufacturing, and even lens production.
The SF series from Atlas Copco is ideal for environments like dentist offices. Imagine an already unpleasant visit to the dentist made worse by the smell of oil and the noise of loud compressors. The SF series eliminates these concerns with a sound-insulated canopy reducing noise levels to as low as 53dB(A). Its small footprint allows for installation close to the point of use.
The SF series features a capacity range of 1.9 to 7.6 l/s (4.03 to 16.10 cfm), a maximum working pressure of 10 bar (145 psi), and a dew point performance as low as 2°C/36°F. Its air-cooled scroll element ensures efficiency, reliability, and durability, while the premium efficiency IE3 class motor lowers energy consumption. Most importantly, the SF series produces absolutely clean air.
Atlas Copco’s oil-free compressors, certified ISO 8573-1 Class 0, set a new standard in air quality, exceeding testing requirements. These features make the SF series indispensable in maintaining a pleasant and hygienic environment in dentist offices, contributing to a less unpleasant visit for patients.
We hope this guide provides a good overview of whether or not a scroll compressor makes sense for your needs. If you'd like more information, feel free to get in touch. Our team is happy to point you in the right direction.
Ask an air system professional about best scroll compressors for your needs.
We’ll compare scroll vs screw compressors along with their pros, cons, and suitable industries and applications for each to help you make an informed decision.
The SF and SF+, including Elektronikon® control, oil-free scroll compressors provide pure, oil-free air for critical applications. Compact, quiet, easy to use and cost-efficient. Read more.
The SFR orbiting scroll compressor is an oil-free, low maintenance compressed air solution validated for all mobility applications. Reliable, rated for a 100% duty cycle and suited for the harshest conditions. The SFR offers performance and flexibility with low noise levels, vibrations and life cycle costs. To be installed on top of, inside or underneath the vehicle; special light-weight models for electric and hybrid buses. Available from 200 to 1550 l/min (7 to 55 cfm) free air delivery
30 June, 2022
There are a lot of things you have to consider when choosing an air compressor for your business. In this article we will explain what compressor is best suited for you, based on your application and needs.
1 July, 2022
Discover the working principle of screw compressors exploring its types, applications, and Atlas Copco's leading technology for UAE industries.
4 August, 2022
Compressed air is all around us, but what is it exactly? Let us introduce you to the world of compressed air and the basic workings of a compressor.